The psychology of self defense and the force continuum
By Syd
You have made the decision to legally carry a self
defense firearm. You have selected a pistol, acquired a CCW license
and hopefully learned the basics of using all of this exciting new
firepower. You have spent a lot of energy learning about
pistols,
cartridges, holsters, and the laws and rules concerning the carry of
deadly weapons. That is all good and necessary, but it is woefully
incomplete. Hopefully, a moment will come when you will step back from
it all for a minute to consider what you are doing.
"If your only tool is a hammer, every problem
looks like a nail," said Abraham Maslow and it was
brilliant. Nowhere is this more true than in the real world use of
defensive firearms. The point I'm going to make and make again, is
that we need to insure that the gun isn't our only tool.
The use of a defensive firearm is not an appropriate
response to the vast majority of threats, hurts and insults we
receive. For normal people who don’t work in law enforcement or the
military, situations in which armed self defense is justified are
actually quite rare. The odds are good that you may live your whole
life without ever needing to draw a gun and fire it at another human
being. I hope you do.
When you strap on a gun, you are introducing into
your life the possibility that you may shoot and kill another person.
This is extremely serious business. No right thinking person wants to
shoot someone. It is a tragic and horrible thing. It is expensive in
every way and creates a profound legal liability. It may create an
emotional and spiritual trauma. People respond to this in different
ways, some having a great deal of "post traumatic stress"
while others seem able to shrug it off pretty easily. One way or the
other, it leaves a mark on your soul. You don’t want to shoot
someone if you don’t have to.
While the presence of the gun may resolve the
problem without it ever being fired or even drawn, it may not, and you
need to be mentally prepared to use it. By the same token, you must be
perfectly clear about the correct and legal use of deadly force, and
you must be emotionally capable of controlling yourself so as not to
use the gun when its use is inappropriate. Your mind is the true
weapon. Everything else is just a tool. If your mind is not prepared,
the hardware will be useless. If the mind is not prepared, the
hardware is more likely to get you into trouble than out of it. If
your mind and body are prepared, you will not need to use the gun
except in the gravest extreme.
The Spiritual Dimension
All of the world’s great religions contain
prohibitions against the wanton destruction of fellow human beings.
This is good. We don’t want to be killing each other over parking
spaces. My own tradition is Judeo-Christian, so I will tend to speak
from that background. One of my own struggles revolved around the fact
that on the surface, arming myself seemed to run contrary to the
religious tradition with which I was raised: "Thou shall not
kill," "Turn the other cheek," and "Blessed are
the peacemakers." How do you resolve this with a .45 auto
strapped to your hip?
First of all, we recognize that these ancient rules
are still good ones. They still make sense. They are the rules I want
to live by. I don’t want to kill anybody. I don’t want to get into
fights just because someone says something obnoxious to me. I want to see
peace in the world. I would love to see a world so peaceful and good
that the assertion of my right to keep and bear arms would be nothing
more than an exercise in constitutional law. Choosing to take
responsibility for the safety and security of yourself and your family
is not a repudiation of the basic injunctions not to murder and to
seek peace and human decency for all.
There are evils greater than death. History is full
of examples which show that it is the moral choice to oppose evil. We
don’t have to look very far: Hitler, Saddam Hussein, Osama bin
Laden, the Khmer
Rouge, the domestic terrorists who have attacked our schools and work
places, the psychopathic predators who have roamed our streets.
Soldiers, law enforcement, and citizens who have opposed this sort of
evil with deadly force are making a moral choice, and if they kill in
the course of fighting this sort of evil, they have committed no
"sin." If you had Hitler or bin Laden in your sights, would
you take the shot?
The demand by the radical pacifists and gun grabbers
that we should accept brutalization and death at the hands of
criminals and psychopaths for the sake of their notion of
"safety" is irrational to the point of being demonic. If
being raped and murdered by a crack head is someone’s idea of
spiritual development, then count me out.
You have the right to live without the threat of
abuse, torture and murder. You have the right to defend yourself. You
have the right to freedom and self-determination, and you have the
right to defend these things with deadly force if necessary. If anyone
tries to tell you otherwise, simply remind them that the very right to
discuss these things and pursue those religious and political beliefs
freely was won by force of arms, not by rolling over and playing dead.
But "turn the other cheek"? Not only is it
a good idea, it's absolutely mandatory in the legal environment in
which we operate. When you begin to carry a personal defense weapon,
you will immediately notice an increased reticence to get involved in
the macho matches in which you may have engaged previously. Generally,
you can only use lethal force for self defense or the defense of
another in response to an imminent threat of bodily harm, sexual
assault or kidnap. If you initiate a pissing match with someone which
escalates into a shooting, your self defense justification is negated.
You will go to jail. Consequently, civility, forbearance, and patience
are absolutely mandatory for the armed civilian (and that includes law
enforcement personnel). So "Turn the other cheek,"
"Blessed are the peacemakers," and "Thou shall not
murder" will serve you well. Avoidance of conflict is always the
best policy. This is the paradox of the concealed personal defense
weapon: we equip, train and prepare ourselves and then we must make
every effort to avoid employing it.
If you think that your gun makes you ten feet tall
and enables you to be rude, confrontational, and gives you god-like
power over the people around you, think again because you're on your
way to jail. You just don't know it yet.
Bushido
So how do we make sure that we have more tools than
just a hammer? The short answer is to prepare mind and body so that
the situations in which the gun would need to be deployed will be
reduced to an absolute minimum. This means the development of
"empty hand" and non-lethal techniques of self defense, and
improved situational awareness.
With the disclaimers that I don’t read or speak
Japanese and am not a samurai or any sort of combat god, I want to
talk a bit about Bushido, the "way of the warrior" in
traditional Japanese martial arts. Bushido got a bad rap during World
War II when it was corrupted by the military leaders of Japan to
become the kamikaze cult which led thousands of young men to senseless
deaths. In reality, Bushido is an ancient philosophy and warrior ethic
based in the non-attachment principles of Zen Buddhism. Bushido is not
unlike the chivalric code of the European knights but it is not the
same. It puts emphasis on loyalty, self sacrifice, justice, a sense of
shame, refined manners, purity, modesty, frugality, martial spirit,
honor and affection.
There are a lot of cool and nifty things about
Bushido that are worth studying in their own right but which are
totally irrelevant to the discussion of concealed carry and self
defense. The points of connection are in the paradoxical nature of the
Bushido ethic and the practice of armed self defense. The Bushido
warrior practices detachment from life and death, and from wealth and
personal ego. At the same time, the Bushido warrior has a fanatical
devotion to the development of his craft, to duty, honor, family and
country. The Bushido warrior strives to achieve a profound respect for
justice, life, and fellow human beings. He is detached, free and
fluid, adaptable and relaxed, while being totally focused, ready to
die, and a master of his martial craft. The spiritual quest of the
Bushido warrior is to resolve these paradoxes into a unified personal
balance. He empties himself and becomes the weapon.
The armed civilian faces analogous paradoxes. He or
she must exert a high level of self control. Petty offenses and
insults cannot be allowed to goad one into an armed confrontation. A
high level of skill must be attained in the use of the firearm. If one
must shoot, the shots must be expertly placed. It would be better to
endure a mugging than to shoot three innocent bystanders in the
process of stopping a mugging. The armed civilian must imagine and
rehearse endless possible scenarios in order to be adequately
prepared. What if I am attacked in a crowd? What if I am injured? What
if my gun jams? Part of this process is fantasy and imagination, and
we must do some serious soul-searching to make sure that we aren’t
seduced by the fantasies into desiring or seeking an armed
confrontation. We must be detached and yet devoted to the craft. We
must be free from macho and blood lust and yet ready to apply lethal
force without hesitation if necessary.
The warrior is prepared for combat wherever he is.
It is said that one samurai, who was so poor as to earn his living by
working in a small field, always carried a sword and wore leggings
even in the field. He therefore did not need to go home first if he
was called up. A samurai is a warrior first, whenever and wherever he
is. He doesn’t sleep with his left arm under his body. If he is
attacked when he is in bed, he can prevent the first blow with his
left arm, and can reach for his sword with his dominant arm. He
remembers to find an emergency exit before he sleeps when he stays in
an inn or hotel.
Like the samurai in the story, the best practice for
the CCW holder is to be armed at all times. There are several reasons
for this. If your gun is on you, it isn’t laying around unsupervised
somewhere and it is available to you in case you need it. If you get
into the practice of wearing your gun every day, you will wear it more
naturally and adjust your wardrobe for adequate concealment. When you
wear the gun at all times, the muscles and unconscious learn where the
gun is, making for a faster and more certain draw. This practice of
wearing the gun at all times reinforces the "warrior spirit"
and is the safest mode of storage for a personal defense weapon.
But this article is about making sure that your don’t
have only a hammer. Samurai military training (Bu) included at
least the six martial arts of sword fighting, spear throwing, shooting
bow and arrow, riding, Karate and also the use of firearms. The
samurai didn’t think very highly of firearms, considering them a
dishonorable way to fight, but that’s another story. Apart from the
six martial arts listed above, others were taught, such as swimming,
fighting with clubs (Jitte) and spikes, star-dagger throwing (Shuriken),
fighting with halberd (Naginata), climbing ropes, and spying
and concealment (Ninjitsu).
The samurai schooled in Bushido could employ a wide
range of martial tools along the complete force continuum
in order to deal with a problem. He was in no way limited to his
sword. In the same way, the armed civilian is best served by equipping
himself or herself with a range of tools, both weapons and "empty
hand" techniques. (Karate means "empty hand").
The Force Continuum
The legendary governor of Louisiana, Huey P. Long,
when discussing the political risks inherent in communications, once
said, "Never write what you can phone; never phone what you can
say in person; never say what you can wink." The governor was
describing a continuum of risk and security in communications. For the
armed civilian, we could come up with a parallel list: "Never
shoot what you can baton; never baton what you can spray; never spray
what you can punch; never punch what you can walk away from."
Less is best.
The advantage of having a range of self defense
tools is obvious. If you can subdue an attacker without using a deadly
weapon, you eliminate the possibility of being charged with assault
with a deadly weapon or facing a lawsuit for shooting someone. You
also eliminate the possibility of emotional repercussions in yourself
that might result from a shooting. There are a number of situations,
especially involving close-in surprise attacks, in which the assailant
may already be too close to draw a gun. In these situations, your
hand-to-hand capabilities will be life savers. It has been shown that
an attacker armed with a knife who is within 21’ distance can wound
or kill a person before they can draw a gun. Finally, there are some
places in which you cannot carry a firearm such as an airplane. The
World Trade Center attack of September 11, 2001 demonstrates clearly
the advantage of having empty hand techniques in settings where
firearms are prohibited (whether they should be prohibited in these
settings is another question, but for now, that is our situation).
Which items you add to your personal defense tool
box is an individual decision based on your own appraisal of your
capabilities. Some people add pepper spray, ASP collapsible batons, or
kubotans. The kubotan is a miniature baton developed by Takayuki
Kubota for use by the female officers of the Los Angeles Police
Department as an aid in controlling unruly suspects. It was so
successful that law enforcement agencies nationwide have adopted the
kubotan for their officers. The kubotan can be used for stabilizing
your fist, applying pressure to sensitive parts of an assailant's
body, or gaining leverage on an assailant's wrist or fingers.
You will notice that I haven’t mentioned knives as
a gun alternative. The reason for this is simple: knives are deadly
weapons and the legal penalties for misapplying them are nearly as
rough as with guns. Additionally, anyone who has ever been in a knife
fight will tell you that they are nasty, brutal affairs and should be
avoided whenever possible. Do I carry a fighting knife? Yes, I do. Do
I want to use it? No, not at all.
The point is that if you can "air out" an
opponent with a single well placed punch, immobilize him with a
kubotan, or disarm him with your hands, you are that much ahead of the
legal and emotional game.
Empty Hand
"Karate" literally means "empty
hand." I talk about Karate because of the symbolism of its name
and it happens to be the martial art that I study. There is a
bewildering array of martial arts schools and disciplines. In fact,
probably the hardest part of it is in finding the right school and
discipline. This part is harder than going to the store and buying a
gun. It requires some research, talking to people, and perhaps trying
out several schools before you hit on the right thing for you. I wish
I could tell you it was easy to find the right trainer and school, but
it isn't. However, if you are able to find the right empty hand
discipline, you will find it richly rewarding. My personal favorite
discipline is Karate, but most of the other schools – Tae-Kwon-Do,
Aikido, Kempo, Kung Fu, Ju-Jitsu, or the western military hand-to-hand
disciplines – will serve you well if you develop them.
The obvious benefits of acquiring an empty hand
technique include having an effective mode of self defense for those
times and places in which you absolutely cannot carry a gun, and it
provides you with an alternative to lethal force in situations where a
lower level of force would be sufficient to handle the situation.
Additionally, the regular practice of an empty hand technique
significantly improves your physical condition – improving muscle
tone and quickening reaction time, and thus improving your overall
health and appearance.
There are also benefits which are less obvious.
After a few months of Karate training, I began to notice that I was
moving better and had better control of my pistol at IDPA matches. My
upper body strength and footwork had improved. There is also a subtle
psychological change which comes over you when you know that you are
in good condition and are capable of handling a physical
confrontation. This is largely unconscious, but you project an aura of
self confidence and ability. Predators sense this and tend to move on
to more vulnerable targets. They want any easy kill, not a fight.
Like IDPA in the world of defensive pistolcraft, an
empty hand technique teaches you to perform under pressure. Nothing
simulates real combat, but the testing for belts, sparring, and
performing your moves in the presence of others creates stress and
acclimates you to acting under pressure. The simple practice and
repetition of moves programs them into your muscles and nerves so that
when you need to employ these skills in a crisis, they are there,
automatic and reflexive.
But aren’t guns "the great equalizer?"
Of course they are. That’s why I work so hard as an advocate for
concealed carry and RKBA. I’m not Bruce Lee and never will be, and
if I get cornered by a gang of thugs, I probably won’t try to duke
it out with them using Karate moves. Some people simply aren’t
capable of practicing a martial art due to physical disabilities or
other impediments. However, if you are in reasonably good health and
martial arts training is available to you, I believe you will find it
highly rewarding in a variety of ways, whether you ever use it in a
fight or not. You’ll have another tool in the box and every problem
won’t look like a nail.
Situational Awareness – Zanshin
At the top and bottom of the force continuum is
situational awareness. The Karate term for this is zanshin.
Literally, "zanshin" means something like "remaining
mind," or "continuing awareness." Zanshin applies to
your awareness of the world around you. You notice the people around
you – how they stand, how they carry themselves, what is in their
eyes – because you need to be prepared to interact with them. You
are present in the moment. The greatest self defense tool you have is
between your ears. When you are aware of the world around you, you can
head off and avoid 99.44% of the situations which might force you to
deploy a weapon. Even Gichin Funakoshi, the "father of modern
Karate" said avoidance was the best strategy, and, if confronted
by an armed [with a knife] opponent, run if you can. In the same way,
if you are planning on going somewhere that you think you’ll need
your battle rifle, two backup pistols and a kevlar vest, just don’t
go there. If you find yourself somewhere that doesn’t "feel
right," leave. A little bit of common sense can spare you of a
lot of grief and lawyer bills. If you can’t avoid the situation,
your zanshin will prepare you to respond effectively and
appropriately.
The Warrior’s Way
You have decided not to be a victim. You have
embarked on the warrior’s way. It is my hope for you that this will
all remain a fascinating but academic exercise, and that you will
never have to face a mugging, attempted rape or home invasion. Yet, in
arming yourself and making the decision not to be food, you have, in
fact, adopted a way of life that makes particular spiritual, physical,
philosophical and legal demands upon you. These rules and demands are
non-negotiable. Misuse lethal force and you may win the battle but
lose the war. By understanding and mastering the force continuum you
can win the battle and win the war.
To summarize, the warrior
- Learns the laws under which he or she
operates,
- Develops "fighting spirit,"
- Acquires mastery of the weapons he or she
chooses to employ,
- Develops self control, good manners, and
respect for others,
- Acquires a range of tools along the force
continuum,
- Develops a continuing situational awareness.
|